by Larry Kolvoord, American-Statesman
1990
PICNIC? Yes, July 4 in Zilker Park.
WHAT HAPPENED:The Highwaymen returned for a family-friendly picnic in the heart of Austin that drew a good-natured crowd of about 12,000 to 15,000. Advance ticket prices were a modest $7 and there was plenty of shade and free water to offset temperatures that hit 101 degrees.
LINEUP: Included Shelby Lynne and Little Joe y la Familia.
QUOTE: “(This is) the best party in the U.S. … These are good, gentle people, and there are a lot of families here,” Thom Steinbeck (son of author John Steinbeck) told the Statesman, proving that 1990 was a long way from 1976.
1991
PICNIC? No.
WHAT HAPPENED: After the IRS implosion, Willie had to make some money – and the Picnic couldn’t even be counted on to break even. Willie spent the week of July 4 playing sold-out shows at the uppity Paul Masson Mountain Winery in Saratoga, Calif.
1992
PICNIC? No.
WHAT HAPPENED: Willie took a step even further back from the Picnic, when he opened a nightclub in Branson, Mo. on July 4. Branson? Yes. And the venue was called “Willie and Poohbah’s Restaurant and Songwriter’s Showcase.” The venue didn’t last long, and neither did Willie’s stay in Branson.
1993
PICNIC? Sorta. July 4 at the Backyard in Bee Cave.
WHAT HAPPENED: After a few years off, Willie eased back into the saddle with a mini-Picnic to celebrate the opening of Tim O’Connor’s new venue. Originally billed as a “Geezinslaws Fourth of July Picnic,” sanity ultimately prevailed and it was made clear that Willie would be closing the show. About 3,000 attended.
1994
PICNIC? No.
WHAT HAPPENED: We have no idea where Willie was on July 4 or what he was doing.
1995
PICNIC? Yes, July 4 in Luckenbach.
WHAT HAPPENED:In a truly inspired turn, the picnic found the perfect venue (lack of nearby accommodations and conservative Gillespie County law enforcement notwithstanding) and brought in new crowds of college kids eager to try their hand at a Texas tradition. The 11-acre town was packed with 13,000 picnickers (for once, a bigger crowd than expected), many jammed into the area in front of the stage, the rest taking refuge in the nicely shaded vendor area across the creek.
LINEUP: Included Robert Earl Keen and T. Bingo.
QUOTE: “Did you see that?” Keen told the San Angelo Standard-Times immediately after leaving the stage. His newly revved-up version of “The Road Goes on Forever” had sent the front half of the crowd into a frenzy, tossing beer cans into the air to the point that the scene resembled a giant popcorn popper.
1996
PICNIC? Yes, July 4 in Luckenbach.
WHAT HAPPENED: Waylon happened. At the tail end of one of the hottest Picnics in the last dozen years, Waylon Jennings finally showed up on stage. He wasn’t in the best shape and he only did a handful of songs, but – after what seemed to be a fair amount of negotiating with Willie – Waylon did perform “Luckenbach, Texas” in his one and only trip to the tiny town, and it was a magical moment.
A drought that year had turned the picnic site into a dustbowl and the heat was fierce. But 12,000 showed up anyway and drank enough water that by 5 p.m., concessionaires had run out. They didn’t slack on the beer either … by one count, more than 55,000 beers were sold.
LINEUP: Included 8 1/2 Souvenirs and the Supersuckers.
QUOTE: “Hell, I don’t know, can’t count ‘em all on my fingers, ‘cause I ain’t got but six fingers,” Billy Joe Shaver told the Standard-Times, when asked how many Picnics he had played.
1997
PICNIC? Yes, July 4 in Luckenbach.
WHAT HAPPENED: Another crowd of about 10,000 for another year in Luckenbach. Nothing beats experience and know-how, it seemed, when it came to smooth-running Picnics. The only real problem? Merle Haggard has a heart attack days before and can’t make the show. The highlight of the afternoon comes when Dwight Yoakam drops in on Joe Ely’s set for a pair of Buddy Holly tunes.
1998
PICNIC? Yes, July 4 in Luckenbach.
WHAT HAPPENED: Emmylou Harris brought the Picnic boys’ club a bit of beauty and a light rain provided relief from the heat. Not to say that the Picnic is getting on in years, but when Asleep at the Wheel got going in their early set, a couple of old guys in the crowd were seen thrusting their canes in the air. The fourth Picnic in Luckenbach draws about 12,000 mellow picnickers.
LINEUP: Included the Derek O’Brien Blues Band and Toni Price.
QUOTE: “It’s about the same, nothing out of the ordinary,” Gillespie County Chief Deputy Sheriff Mel Gideon told the Statesman, showing that after four in a row, even local law enforcement isn’t worked up about the Picnic.
1999
PICNIC? Yes, July 4 in Luckenbach.
WHAT HAPPENED: The picnic got off to a sobering start at 10 a.m. Literally. It was Sunday morning and beer sales were prohibited until noon. Once again, attendance topped 10,000 and the weather was uncharacteristically cool. On his bus, Willie talked about Luckenbach as a permanent spot for the picnic and nobody disagreed.
LINEUP: Included Larry Gatlin and Pat Green.
2000
PICNIC? Yes, July 4 at Southpark Meadows.
WHAT HAPPENED:The picnic had been prepared to make the move to the brand new Stone Mountain Center west of Dripping Springs, when a new law regarding mass gatherings and county permits became known. (Previously a permit was not required unless the event ran more than 12 hours – which is why after 12 hours the plug was pulled in Luckenbach without fail, no matter how little Willie had played. Now the cutoff was 5 hours.) The deadline had passed to get a proper permit, so the Picnic returned to Southpark Meadows (which was already zoned for such events). After 5 years in Luckenbach, Southpark Meadows didn’t seem to have a lot of soul, but the easy parking and nearby accommodations couldn’t be beat. More than 11,000 attended.
LINEUP: Included Jimmie Dale Gilmore and Mark David Manders.
2001
PICNIC? No.
WHAT HAPPENED:The Picnic was set to make its return to Luckenbach, but by mid-May Willie had enough of the problems surrounding the required permits and other hoops to be jumped through. The Picnic was off. A Shreveport Times interview with Willie later that summer revealed Willie spent the holiday playing golf, swimming, visiting with friends and relatives and watching fireworks. “I’ve never been off on the Fourth, ever in my life,” he said.
QUOTE: “We’re really bummed. But we’ve been here (153 years), and we’ll still be here when Willie decides to throw another one,” Luckenbach mayor VelAnne Howle told the Statesman.
2002
PICNIC? No.
WHAT HAPPENED: The Picnic made its last effort to return to Luckenbach and a permit was granted in early April, but the conditions that Gillespie County insisted on weren’t tolerable to Willie. By early May, he had made the decision to call off the Picnic again.
Pat Green tried to step in and fill the void with a July 4 show at Waterloo Park in Austin. Research hasn’t revealed how Willie spent the Fourth.
2003
PICNIC? Yes, July 4-5 at Two River Canyon Amphitheater near Spicewood.
WHAT HAPPENED: The picnic made one final effort to really bring back the old days: a two-day event on a ranch-made-venue out in the country with camping, reasonable concessions and as much big-name talent as they could pack in.
The Two River Canyon Amphitheater was born with dreams of it being Texas’ answer to Red Rocks, and promoters referred to their two-day Picnic as “Hillstock.” But the Picnic was a victim of its own success: an hourslong traffic jam backed up Texas 71 for miles on the Fourth, with many concertgoers headed toward the show at the same time to catch the Dead (no longer Grateful, after Jerry Garcia’s demise).
Unlike the 1970s, however, most people weren’t going to abandon their cars by the side of the road and hoof it to the venue. One would-be picnicker would later write the Statesman, trying to find out how to get her money back after waiting “over an hour to move a quarter-mile.”
The music was a hit and the event was typical Willie – with the host singing alongside Toby Keith one moment, and bringing politician Dennis Kucinich onstage the next.
About 22,000 attended July 4, and about 17,000 came out on July 5. Traffic the second day was easy, the weather cooperated both days and there were few injuries or arrests to speak of … but the damage was done. Two River Canyon Amphitheater had shown it had fantastic potential, but it was done in by one big traffic jam. Sadly, it would never host another event.
LINEUP: Included Patty Griffin and Billy Bob Thornton.
QUOTE: “A woman called and said Willie told her that her band could play. This was less than two weeks before the Fourth. But I called Willie and he confirmed it, so she’s on the bill. That’s the Picnic for you,” Tim O’Connor told the Statesman, revealing the go-with-the-flow mentality of putting on the Picnic.
2004
PICNIC? Yes, July 4 in Fort Worth.
WHAT HAPPENED: As the Picnic entered its golden years, it evolved in yet another remarkable way. The Fort Worth Stockyards, specifically the North Forty behind Billy Bob’s, provided an outdoor venue, surrounded by hotels, city transportation and large air-conditioned buildings. The in-and-out policy offered flexibility unimaginable to picnic veterans of the ‘70s. Don’t want to eat a giant turkey leg? Go to a nearby steakhouse. Feeling a little overheated? Cool off in a nearby bar. Don’t have a designated driver? Flag down a taxi outside the gates.
The bad news? The novelty of a Fort Worth Picnic drew a crowd of more than 20,000 – more than was comfortable. As the afternoon wore on and people poured in, early arrivals would find they were boxed in, with no routes to port-a-potties or beer stands other than stepping over and sometimes on fellow picnickers. Tempers flared, fueled by the heat and not eased at all by the comedy sets of Larry the Cable Guy or Ron White. Later in the evening, Kris Kristofferson’s more liberal-minded songs drew grumblings from many in the crowd.
A large stable of corporate sponsors didn’t feel right, but the Picnic made the most of their money, installing two stages to erase the time the audience spent waiting for sets to be stripped down and gear to be set up. The show stayed on schedule, the music flowed easily and sweet air conditioning wasn’t far away.
LINEUP: Included Cross Canadian Ragweed and Clarence “Gatemouth” Brown.
QUOTE: “It was naked hippies last year. This is drunk rednecks,” a picnicker told the Dallas Morning News, spelling out the difference between Spicewood and Fort Worth.
2005
PICNIC? Yes, July 4 in Fort Worth.
WHAT HAPPENED: The Stockyards – kind of a Sixth Street for rednecks – proved comfortable enough to bring back the Picnic for a second year. This time 18,000 were on hand, but 2,000 fewer people made a big difference in being able to navigate the North Forty. Bob Dylan was the big draw, playing a long set for a divided crowd: Half hung on every word, half were respectfully waiting for a song they recognized. That moment came when Dylan launched into “Like a Rolling Stone” and the floodlights came on, illuminating not the crowd but the dust that hung in the air, giving everything a ghostly sheen.
The new millennium had erased all vestiges of the “Outlaw” era: By 7:30 p.m. one Fort Worth police officer said there hadn’t been a single arrest. “We haven’t even escorted anyone out.”
LINEUP: Included the Doobie Brothers and Pauline Reese.
2006
PICNIC? Yes, July 4 in Fort Worth.
WHAT HAPPENED: A Tuesday Picnic drew fewer than 12,000, with no Bob Dylan to draw in the curious. But that just made everything a lot more comfortable for those who showed up. There was a Nelson, a Haggard and a Jennings on the bill, but they were Paula Nelson, Noel Haggard and Shooter Jennings. Waylon’s son, making his Picnic debut a decade after his father’s final Picnic appearance, stole the show in the mid-afternoon. Another Outlaw offspring, Lucas Hubbard, son of Ray Wylie, stole the show right back that evening, playing blistering guitar for his dad. Yes, the Picnic has reached that age.
The day began with a stifling combination of heat and humidity, but an intense rain shower (that shut down both stages for at least half an hour) cleared that up, only to leave the North Forty a muddy mess.
LINEUP: Included the Nitty Gritty Dirt Band and Folk Uke.
QUOTE: “I don’t know. It’s still fun,” Willie Nelson, when asked by the Statesman how long he intended to keep hosting the Fourth of July Picnic.
2007
PICNIC? Sorta. July 4 at the Gorge Amphitheater in Washington.
WHAT HAPPENED: You can blame David Letterman for this. An agreement to play his Montana ranch on July 3 apparently led to this pseudo-Picnic. If Willie had hoped to escape the Texas heat, it didn’t quite work out. Temperatures brushed 100 degrees for the half-day show that featured Son Volt and the Old 97s instead of longtime Picnic cohorts such as Leon Russell and Johnny Bush.
LINEUP: Included the Drive-By Truckers and 40 Points.
2008
PICNIC? Yes. July 4 at the Verizon Wireless Amphitheater in Selma and July 5 at the Sam Houston Race Park in Houston.
WHAT HAPPENED: Nearly nothing of note at the dying amphitheater in Selma, where a small rain shower soaked a smaller afternoon crowd and David Allan Coe, dressed in black, performed against a backdrop of black. You couldn’t swing an overpriced T-shirt without hitting a vendor hawking overpriced beers. Ray Wylie Hubbard had the best set, even escaping without playing “Redneck Mother.” Houston also had early-afternoon rains, but a more spirited atmosphere, even though Merle Haggard continued a Picnic tradition of calling in sick. Attendance figures weren’t available for either show.
LINEUP: Included Los Lonely Boys and Del Castillo, but, mysteriously, no Leon Russell.
QUOTE: “I’m going to do a song I did so many years ago I don’t tell anyone when I did it,” Ray Price, 82, joking with the San Antonio crowd.
2009
PICNIC? Not really. July 4 at South Bend, Indiana.
WHAT HAPPENED: Bob Dylan, Willie and John Mellencamp went on a tour of minor league baseball parks in July and August of 2009. With July 4 falling on a Saturday, a stop at Coveleski Stadium was promoted as a “Fourth of July Picnic” and Willie took Dylan’s closing spot for the night. Reviews were favorable and a crowd of 8,500 packed the park, but it was a Picnic in promotion only.
2010
PICNIC? Yes. July 4 at the Backyard in Bee Cave.
WHAT WILL HAPPEN: The Picnic will be back in the hands of Tim O’Connor at the new Backyard. The veteran Picnic performers will all be there for a more traditional show. The venue only holds 7,500, though. Will the Picnic be packed? Will it be reinvigorated? Or is this a benediction for a Texas tradition?